“Mangomint already shows client retention.”
It shows retention for clients you have. It cannot show which marketing produced the ones who stay, because it never saw the ad.
For Mangomint
Export your tickets from Mangomint, upload the leads that produced them, and rank marketing on client value rather than on bookings.
CloseRev reads a Mangomint export of tickets — the client's phone or email, the amount taken and the date — and matches it against the ads, calls and forms that produced the first booking. A salon or med spa client is a series of visits and a retail relationship, so a channel's worth is what its clients spend over months rather than what they spent on arrival. Tickets with no traceable lead are reported as Direct / Unknown.
Page updated September 24, 2026.
The gap
Instagram says it produced bookings. Your till says what came in. Nobody has ever put those two sentences in the same report.
What was sold, to whom, and for how much.
The click, the keyword, the call, and what each one cost.
The file
Three things carry the match: who, how much, and when. Anything else is optional and only changes how the report can be sliced.
On the client record rather than the ticket. Bookings arrive online and by phone in roughly equal measure, so both columns matter for coverage.
Everything on the ticket — service, retail, gratuity if you count it consistently, and any package or gift card redeemed against it.
When the visit was paid for. Prepaid packages are better attributed on the date they were bought than on each redemption.
The salon or spa, mapped as Location, for a business with more than one. Services and providers stay out of the file: on a med spa client's row, an injectable or the injector who gave it is health information CloseRev does not take.
Step by step
Written for somebody with Mangomint open in the next tab. Report names vary by edition, so each step says what to look for.
One row per ticket with a client contact detail, the total and a date. Include retail lines rather than service revenue alone.
A first visit on an introductory price tells you almost nothing. The channel's value is what the client spent across the following visits.
Paid social, local search, the booking widget and any marketplace listing, combined into one lead file with a contact detail and the source on every row.
A regular client appears many times, and each ticket counts as a sale. Revenue per channel is right either way; sum per client before uploading if you want the count to mean clients.
The join is the phone and the email, normalized. Repeat visits carry the same contact and credit the channel behind the first booking.
What comes back
Revenue by channel, the count of sales behind each figure, and an honest bucket for the ones nobody could trace. Sample figures, from the worked example on the Med Spas & Dermatology page — not from a Mangomint account.
| Channel | Share | Sales | Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meta Ads | 96 | $78,200 | |
| Google Ads | 61 | $55,200 | |
| Email marketing | 44 | $32,200 | |
| Direct / Unknown | 79 | $64,400 |
Unmatched sales stay in Direct / Unknown. They are never spread across the paid channels to make the total look better.
The argument
Salons and med spas sell product at the counter, and the margin on it is better than the margin on chair time. It is also unevenly distributed: a minority of clients buy most of it.
That propensity travels with the kind of client a channel brings rather than with the service they booked. A channel producing clients who buy product is worth materially more than one producing clients who do not, at identical booking counts.
Export tickets rather than service revenue and the ranking can shift. It is the cheapest correction available in this category.
In a salon, clients who ask for a particular stylist or injector return far more reliably than clients who take whoever is available.
That loyalty shows up without a provider column: a channel whose clients settle and return carries their later tickets as revenue, credited to the first booking, so the channel that produces regulars ranks above the one that produces one-off visits. That is a better predictor of a year's revenue than anything in the booking data.
What the report cannot show is which provider holds a channel's clients. That stays in Mangomint's own reporting, so a channel whose clients all landed with one person is a risk to check there — nothing in a cost-per-booking report would ever have warned you.
A package bought in January and redeemed across six months puts cash in on one date and service out on six others. A gift card does the same across two different people.
Attributing on redemption spreads one decision across half a year and credits whatever was running each time. Attributing on purchase keeps it with the campaign that produced the sale.
So put the package purchase in the file as the sale, and keep redemptions out or at zero, so the same money is not counted twice.
This is a visual category with a visual buyer, so most of the budget goes to platforms with view-through windows, modeled conversions and in-app booking.
Those platforms will report a booking. They cannot report whether the client turned up, what they spent, or whether they came back — and all three differ by channel.
Reading tickets against the lead file replaces platform-reported conversions with money taken, and where the ranking moves, it moves on that.
Fair questions
It shows retention for clients you have. It cannot show which marketing produced the ones who stay, because it never saw the ad.
Then the question is which campaigns and which offers, and the till is the only judge that does not report in its own favor.
That is fine and it matches well. Export the phone column too so phone bookings are not silently excluded.
No. It reads a file you exported, so your calendar, your client notes and your card vault are never reachable from here.
Tickets with a client contact detail, the total and a date.
Yes. It carries better margin than chair time and it travels with the kind of client a channel brings.
Six months at minimum. A first visit at an introductory price measures the discount, not the client.
Attribute on the purchase date rather than on each redemption, so one decision is not spread across six months of campaigns.
The purchase and the redemption are two different people. Attribute the purchase; the redeeming client is a new relationship of their own.
Not in CloseRev; provider reports stay in Mangomint. The report splits by location where you map one, and a channel whose clients return shows it in its revenue.
Yes. Repeat visits carry the same contact, so they credit the channel behind the first booking.
They sit in Direct / Unknown. In a salon that bucket is usually walk-ins, and its size is worth knowing.
Yes: map the location column as Location. A two-site average usually describes neither site.
A contact detail, an amount and a date, plus the location if you include one. No service names, no treatment notes, no photographs, no consent forms, no card data. Encrypted in transit and at rest and deleted with the import.
Revenue by channel over months, repeat visits credited to the channel behind the first booking, and everything unmatched kept visible.
By trade
What the report looks like once the export is in, written for each one.
Other systems
Running more than one system, or comparing? The method is the same and the columns are not.
Mangomint and the other product names and logos on this page belong to their owners and are shown to identify the software a file comes from. CloseRev is not affiliated with or endorsed by them, and connects to none of them: it reads a file you export.
From the blog
Multi-site healthcare groups usually conclude that attribution is off limits because the data is clinical. It is not, because attribution does not need clinical data. What it needs is a phone number, an amount and a date, and there is a way to handle even those properly.
Read the articleA multi-location business that reports one national attribution number is hiding its most important finding. The same campaign performs differently in every market, and the aggregate is an average of things that should never have been averaged.
Read the articleThe channel with the cheapest leads is often the one whose leads almost never buy. Lead conversion rate by source divides the new customers each channel produced by the real, deduplicated leads it sent, counted by the month the lead arrived. Here is the formula, what to take out of the denominator, why small counts lie, how revenue per lead and cost per customer follow from it, and a five-channel worked example.
Read the articleStart today
Nothing to install in Mangomint, no API key, and no need to have been tracking anything until now. Last year works as well as this month.