“Roofr already tracks proposal acceptance.”
It does, inside the system. It has no record of the canvasser, the ad or the storm list that produced the homeowner.
For Roofr
Export signed work from Roofr, upload the leads behind it, and rank channels on contracts rather than on how many roofs you measured.
CloseRev reads a Roofr export of signed proposals or invoices — the homeowner's phone or email, the amount and the date — and matches it against the calls, forms and canvassing that produced the lead. Roofing is a trade where a proposal costs almost nothing to produce and a signature is worth five figures, which makes lead counts an especially poor guide to what a channel is worth. Signed work with no traceable lead is reported as Direct / Unknown.
Page updated September 24, 2026.
The gap
Proposals are cheap to send, so every channel looks productive until somebody counts signatures.
What was sold, to whom, and for how much.
The click, the keyword, the call, and what each one cost.
The file
Three things carry the match: who, how much, and when. Anything else is optional and only changes how the report can be sliced.
On the customer or proposal record. Phone is the working key in roofing.
The accepted contract value. A sent proposal is not revenue however good the measurement was.
When it was accepted. Keep the lead date too — storm work and planned replacement have very different lags.
Repair, replacement, insurance claim, mapped as Product / service. Their values and their sources differ enormously.
Step by step
Written for somebody with Roofr open in the next tab. Report names vary by edition, so each step says what to look for.
One row per signed job with a homeowner contact detail, the amount and the date.
Every homeowner who got a proposal belongs in the lead file. A channel that needs ten proposals per signature costs ten measurements, and that cost is invisible without them.
Canvassing, tracked numbers, search ads, the website form, storm lists and any marketplace you buy from.
Roofing is seasonal and weather-driven, and a quarter compares storms rather than channels.
The join runs on the phone and the email, normalized. Leads that never signed stay in the report as the cost of the channel that produced them.
What comes back
Revenue by channel, the count of sales behind each figure, and an honest bucket for the ones nobody could trace. Sample figures, from the worked example on the Roofing Contractors page — not from a Roofr account.
| Channel | Share | Sales | Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Ads | 19 | $342,000 | |
| Meta Ads | 9 | $153,000 | |
| Email marketing | 3 | $45,000 | |
| Direct / Unknown | 21 | $360,000 |
Unmatched sales stay in Direct / Unknown. They are never spread across the paid channels to make the total look better.
The argument
When a measurement and a branded proposal take minutes rather than an afternoon, the natural instinct is to quote everything that moves.
That is good operations and it destroys lead-based reporting, because the proposal count stops carrying any information about whether the lead was real.
The number that still means something is the signature, and ranking channels on signed value rather than on proposals sent can reorder the list substantially.
It also puts a cost on the volume: a source needing ten proposals per signature is consuming ten measurements, ten follow-ups and ten days of somebody's attention.
None of that appears in a cost-per-lead figure, and all of it is paid by the business.
A hailstorm produces two weeks of inquiries that no advertising caused, at values set by an insurance adjuster rather than by your pricing.
Planned replacement is a slow, considered purchase where the homeowner has been thinking about the roof for a year and compares three contractors.
Blended, the storm weeks inflate whichever channel happened to be running, and the conclusion will not repeat because the weather will not.
Mapped as Product / service, a job type or insurance flag lets the report cut revenue by it; where the export has neither, narrowing the report's date range isolates the storm weeks.
The point is not to discard storm revenue but to stop it being read as proof that a campaign worked.
Door-knocking after a weather event can produce a large share of roofing revenue, and it has a real cost in wages and time.
Because no invoice arrives from an advertising platform, it sits outside every marketing report and the paid channels are judged as though they were the whole budget.
Canvassing as a source in the lead file puts it into the same comparison on the same signed value, to set against what it actually cost to have people walking streets.
The ranking between canvassing and paid search need not be what either side of the argument assumed.
With the crew or neighborhood in the campaign column, the drill-down also shows which of them produce signatures, which is a scheduling decision rather than a marketing one.
A claim-funded replacement has a value set by the adjuster, a longer timeline, and a conversion pattern driven by the claim rather than by your sales process.
Averaged with retail work it produces a figure describing neither, and a channel weighted towards claims will be read as though it produced retail jobs.
Mapped as Product / service, the split shows each line's revenue on its own, and the matched-records export pairs every job with its channel, so the sources feeding each can be compared — they may be almost entirely different.
Where the export flags the claim, map that flag as Product / service. Where it does not, add one to the sales file before uploading; the report will not guess which jobs were claims.
Fair questions
It does, inside the system. It has no record of the canvasser, the ad or the storm list that produced the homeowner.
Then the report will show that honestly, and separating it is how you find out what the rest of the marketing is worth.
A code on the lead record is enough. It does not need to be digital to be comparable on money.
No. It reads an exported file, so your measurements, proposals and customer records stay where they are.
Signed proposals or invoices with a homeowner contact detail, the amount and the date.
Because each one cost a measurement and a follow-up, and a channel needing ten per signature is far more expensive than its lead price.
A year; there is no window to set. Roofing is seasonal and weather-driven, and a quarter compares storms.
Map a job type or insurance flag as Product / service, or narrow the report's date range to the storm, so weather is not mistaken for marketing.
Yes, as a source in the lead file with the canvasser code in the campaign column, ranked on the same signed value as every paid channel.
Yes. Their values are set by an adjuster and averaging them with retail work describes neither.
Map the job type as Product / service where the export carries it. A repair and a full replacement are different decisions with different sources.
From the matched-records export, which carries the lead date beside the signed date; the report itself dates revenue by the signature. That is how a seasonal budget gets decided.
Anything with no traceable lead, such as untracked calls and referrals, and its size is worth knowing.
A contact detail, an amount and a date, plus a job type if you include one. No property addresses required, no measurements, no claim documents. Encrypted in transit and at rest and deleted with the import.
Signed value per source with its leads and signed jobs beside it, revenue cut by job type where you map one, and everything unmatched kept visible.
By trade
What the report looks like once the export is in, written for each one.
Other systems
Running more than one system, or comparing? The method is the same and the columns are not.
Roofr and the other product names and logos on this page belong to their owners and are shown to identify the software a file comes from. CloseRev is not affiliated with or endorsed by them, and connects to none of them: it reads a file you export.
From the blog
Multi-crew home and field services businesses run on phone calls and job management software, not on web forms. Which means the standard marketing dashboard is measuring the smallest part of the business and missing where the money actually is.
Read the articleCall tracking answers one question well: which campaign produced the ring. It has no view of what happened after the call ended, which is where the money is decided. This is what the gap costs, and how to close it without replacing the call tracker you already have.
Read the articleZillow Premier Agent sells connections by share of voice in a zip code, or through Zillow Preferred for a fee when a lead closes, generally within two years. A monthly bill set against this month's closings will mislead you either way. Here is how to measure Zillow ROI by connection cohort, where the break-even between the two pricing models sits, and what to do about leads who were already your clients.
Read the articleStart today
Nothing to install in Roofr, no API key, and no need to have been tracking anything until now. Last year works as well as this month.