“Thumbtack already shows my leads and hires.”
It shows what happens on the platform. What the job was worth is on your invoice, which it never sees.
For Thumbtack
Export your Thumbtack leads, match them against paid jobs, and find out which categories and which job sizes are worth being in.
Thumbtack sits on the lead side in CloseRev: export the leads it sent you, each with the customer's contact details and the job they described, and match them against the invoices in your own system. Customers on a marketplace like this are usually weighing several pros at once, so the useful number is not how many leads arrived but how many ended in a paid job — and at what size. Revenue with no traceable lead is reported as Direct / Unknown.
Page updated September 25, 2026.
The gap
The leads come in at a steady rate. The jobs do not, and the two numbers have never been put side by side.
What was sold, to whom, and for how much.
The click, the keyword, the call, and what each one cost.
The file
Three things carry the match: who, how much, and when. Anything else is optional and only changes how the report can be sliced.
On each lead. Once the customer replies, the contact detail is what joins them to your own records.
What they asked for, with the category as the campaign value. Job size varies enormously within one category, and it decides what a win is worth.
When it arrived; it decides which of a customer's leads came first.
Not read by CloseRev; keep it from your account. Divided by the paid jobs the report counts, it gives cost per paid job.
Step by step
Written for somebody with Thumbtack open in the next tab. Report names vary by edition, so each step says what to look for.
One row per lead with the customer's contact detail, the category and the date.
From your invoicing system: contact detail, amount, date.
A customer who never replied still cost the lead, and they are the part of the file that says most about fit.
Put the category in the campaign column. A pro who does both small repairs and large installs is really in two marketplaces with different economics.
The join runs on the phone and the email, normalized, with every invoice amount in the matched-records export, so job size is visible.
What comes back
Revenue by channel, the count of sales behind each figure, and an honest bucket for the ones nobody could trace. Sample figures, from the worked example on the Home Services page — not from a Thumbtack account.
| Channel | Share | Sales | Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Ads | 54 | $218,600 | |
| Meta Ads | 29 | $66,500 | |
| Email marketing | 17 | $38,000 | |
| Direct / Unknown | 71 | $152,100 |
Unmatched sales stay in Direct / Unknown. They are never spread across the paid channels to make the total look better.
The argument
On a marketplace where the customer describes a job and then looks at several pros, what the pro buys is the chance to be considered.
Whether they are chosen depends on price, reviews, response time and how the profile reads — most of which the pro controls and none of which appears in a lead count.
So a rising lead count with a flat number of paid jobs is not the marketplace getting worse. It is the pro being shortlisted more often and chosen at the same rate.
Matching leads to invoices separates the two, and the win rate that falls out is the number worth working on.
It is also the number most likely to be improved without spending anything more on the marketplace.
Within a single category, a job can be an hour or a week. A lead for each costs broadly the same thing to receive and produces completely different revenue.
Averaged together, the small jobs drag the value of the category down and the large ones make it look better than it is for most leads.
The matched-records export lists every invoice amount, so the distribution can be read rather than only the average the report shows: how many wins were small, how many were large, and which categories produced which.
One or two categories may carry the channel while the rest cost more than they return, which is a settings change rather than a cancellation.
Where customers see several quotes side by side, the ones most likely to reply can be the ones shopping hardest on price.
That is a reasonable market, and it is a different market from a customer who called one business because a neighbor recommended it.
Measured together in one report, they look like the same thing. Measured apart, the marketplace customer may win less often and spend less when they do.
Neither is wrong. Knowing which is which is what lets a pro decide how much of the diary to hand to each.
Many leads go nowhere: the customer hired someone else, changed their mind, or never read the reply.
Dropped from the file, those leads make the channel look efficient; kept, they show how often the pro is being considered and passed over.
Where the pattern concentrates in particular categories, it points at the profile, the pricing or the response time rather than at the marketplace itself.
The report keeps them visible for exactly that reason, next to the leads that became jobs.
Fair questions
It shows what happens on the platform. What the job was worth is on your invoice, which it never sees.
Then that is the most useful part of the file, because it shows where you are being passed over.
Which is why the category goes in the campaign column — a pro in several categories is really in several marketplaces.
No. It reads a file you exported, so your profile, messages and account stay where they are.
Your leads with the customer's contact detail, category and date, plus paid jobs from your own invoicing system.
You paid for them, and they are the clearest signal of where you are being considered and not chosen.
Yes, with the category in the campaign column, and it can be the most useful split. A pro in several categories is effectively in several different marketplaces.
More than anything else in the file. The report shows the average; the matched-records export lists every job value, so the spread is visible too.
Yes, on revenue per lead and cost per paid job, which every channel can be put on.
Long enough for the job to be booked and paid — days for small jobs, longer for larger ones. There is no window to set.
If the contact detail matches, the job is matched to the lead. That is the point of joining on the customer rather than on the platform's own record.
Yes — the report sets paid jobs beside leads, per category where it is in the campaign column, which is the number most likely to improve without extra spend.
Any paid job with no matching lead from any source. Its size is stated rather than distributed.
A contact detail, a category and a date on one side; a contact detail, an amount and a date on the other. No messages, no reviews, no job descriptions beyond the category. Encrypted in transit and at rest and deleted with the import.
Revenue per lead and paid jobs by category, every job value in the matched-records export, quiet leads kept visible, and everything unmatched reported.
By trade
What the report looks like once the export is in, written for each one.
Other systems
Running more than one system, or comparing? The method is the same and the columns are not.
Thumbtack and the other product names and logos on this page belong to their owners and are shown to identify the software a file comes from. CloseRev is not affiliated with or endorsed by them, and connects to none of them: it reads a file you export.
From the blog
Angi, Thumbtack and the other home-service marketplaces charge for an introduction, not a job, and the introduction is often shared. That makes cost per lead the least useful number they report. Here is how to price a marketplace by the paid work it actually produced, and what to do with the answer.
Read the articleIt is easy to compute, easy to improve, and it will happily bankrupt you. A defense of the least popular position in performance marketing: that the metric most teams are held to is actively harmful, and that the alternative is available to anyone willing to do one join.
Read the articleOffline conversion imports let Google and Meta optimize toward money instead of form fills. They also hand a platform your customer list and let it mark its own homework. Here is how to do it without either mistake.
Read the articleStart today
Nothing to install in Thumbtack, no API key, and no need to have been tracking anything until now. Last year works as well as this month.